It is amazing when you really start to look at children’s fantasy how much of it centers around the leading character either being an orphan or adopted.
In the case of the Golden Compass, Lyra the leading character is not really an adoptee as no new parent has adopted her, but is an orphan. Wikipedia describes her as an orphan living in a parallel universe where a child’s soul is represented by an animal daemon who follows them.
An evil empire bent on controlling the world called the Magisterium, kidnaps kiddos. When one of Lyra’s friends is kidnapped she travels north to recover him.
So how does this have anything to do with adoption other than the fact the Lyra is an orphan? Well, Lyra is really not an orphan. While I thought the film was pretty violent for little kiddos, I do applaud the creativity and imagination and the overall theme of film which is about prolonging the “innocence” or imagination of childhood, which is much like what I am trying to achieve with Elona. What I found disturbing outside of the violence, is probably only disturbing to me because I am an adoptive parent.
You see (SPOILER ALERT DON’T READ BEYOND THIS POINT IF YOU PLAN TO SEE THE MOVIE AND WANT TO BE SURPRISED…..seriously, don’t)
For the rest of you…..here’s the problem.

Mrs. Coulter is Lyra’s birth mother and is as wicked and evil a woman as any Disney (which this is not Disney) villian can be. She is the actual epitome of wicked in more evil, controlling, take over the worlding ways to count.
I think that this image perpetuates the stereo-type of the kind of woman that would relinquish their child. That in order to relinquish a child to adoption, the birth mother must somehow be cold and unfeeling.
As a writer with a child whom I will eventually need to discuss her birth mother and her birth mother’s history (which is pretty sordid as I adopted through foster care) I will still want to show her examples of kind people and loving moms who made hard choices. That is how I will try to frame the birth mother in Elona. While it will be in a fantasy realm I will try to paint as realistic (minus the darkness) yet empathetic a picture as I can. Meaning I will use the realms of fantasy to cloud some of the harsh facts.
Films like the Golden Compass who show birth mothers as controlling, evil villains, who want to squash a child’s imagination and innocence are not the kinds of characters that I want my daughter being introduced to early in life while she is trying to understand adoption. I think we would save this film for a time when she has a clear sense about the choices and life her birth mother had, before being exposed to this kind of dramatically negative narrative influence.
So…that being said. As a film the Golden Compass I am sure is just as entertaining and magical as the Lord of the Rings for the kids of that age range, but as a film that deals with adoption, I find the portrayal of yet another evil mother, this time being a birth mother, a little insensitive.
Possibly-related Articles:                                        
(auto-generated)